Choose from a wide range of NEWCV resume templates and customize your NEWCV design with a single click.
A counter offer email is a professional response to a job offer where you thank the employer, confirm your interest, and ask for an improved salary, benefits package, start date, working pattern, or overall offer terms. The best counter offer emails are clear, calm, specific, and commercially sensible. They do not sound demanding, emotional, vague, or apologetic.
In the UK job market, negotiation is normal, but it needs to be handled carefully. By the time an employer makes an offer, they already want you. That gives you leverage. But leverage is not the same as permission to be careless. A good counter offer email protects the relationship while making your value, expectations, and decision criteria easy to understand.
A counter offer email is not just an email asking for more money. That is where many candidates get it wrong.
The real purpose is to help the employer understand what would make the offer acceptable without making them feel they have misjudged you, wasted time, or entered a difficult negotiation with someone who may be awkward to manage later.
That sounds harsh, but it is how hiring conversations often work behind the scenes.
When a candidate sends a counter offer, the recruiter or hiring manager is usually asking themselves:
Is this request reasonable based on the role, market, and candidate level?
Does this candidate still seem genuinely interested?
Are they negotiating professionally or testing us?
Can we justify the increase internally?
If we improve the offer, are they likely to accept?
You should send a counter offer email when you would genuinely accept the role if the offer improved in a specific way.
That matters. A counter offer is not a fishing expedition. It should not be used casually just because someone on LinkedIn told you to “always negotiate”. That advice sounds confident, but hiring is more nuanced than that.
You should usually consider a counter offer if:
The salary is below the market rate for the role
The offer is below the range discussed earlier in the process
You have another offer that is meaningfully stronger
The responsibilities are broader than originally described
The benefits package is weaker than expected
The commute, hybrid arrangement, or working pattern affects the overall value
Most employers do not withdraw an offer just because a candidate negotiates professionally. That fear is usually bigger in the candidate’s head than it is in reality.
But employers do react badly to poor negotiation.
Here is the difference.
A professional counter offer sounds like:
“I’m very interested in the role and appreciate the offer. Based on the scope of the position and the market level for similar roles, I was hoping we could explore whether there is flexibility to move the salary to £X.”
That gives the employer something to work with.
A risky counter offer sounds like:
“I expected more. Can you do better?”
That gives the employer very little. It also creates a tone problem.
The hiring manager may not say it directly, but they will notice how you communicate when there is a small tension point. Salary negotiation is often the first moment where the employer sees how you handle disagreement, pressure, and self advocacy.
This is why the tone matters so much. You are not only negotiating money. You are showing judgement.
Behind the scenes, the recruiter may be thinking:
This candidate is still engaged
The request is specific
A good counter offer email should be short enough to read quickly, but complete enough to avoid confusion.
It should include:
A thank you for the offer
A clear statement that you are interested in the role
The specific part of the offer you want to discuss
A clear counter proposal
A brief reason for the request
A positive closing that keeps the conversation open
You do not need to include your life story. You do not need to explain your rent, mortgage, childcare, train fare, or personal financial pressure. Those things may be real, but they are not usually the strongest negotiation argument.
Employers do not price roles based on your personal expenses. They price roles based on internal salary bands, market benchmarks, budget, urgency, skills scarcity, and how strongly they want you compared with other candidates.
Use this when you want a clean, professional counter offer after receiving a job offer.
Example
Subject: Re: Offer for [Job Title]
Hi [Name],
Thank you again for the offer for the [Job Title] position. I really appreciate the time everyone has taken throughout the process, and I’m genuinely excited about the opportunity to join [Company Name].
After reviewing the offer, I wanted to ask whether there is any flexibility on the salary. Based on the scope of the role, the responsibilities we discussed, and the level of experience I would bring, I was hoping we could explore a salary of £[Counter Offer Amount].
I remain very interested in the position and would be happy to discuss this further if helpful. If there is flexibility to move closer to that figure, I would feel comfortable moving forward.
Kind regards,
[Your Name]
Why this works:
It confirms interest before asking for more
It gives a specific number
It keeps the tone warm and professional
This version is best when the salary is the main issue and you are otherwise happy with the offer.
Example
Subject: Re: [Job Title] Offer
Hi [Name],
Thank you for sending through the offer. I’m really pleased to have received it and I enjoyed speaking with the team throughout the interview process.
I’ve reviewed the details and I’m very interested in the role. The only point I wanted to discuss is the salary. Given the responsibilities of the position and my experience in [brief area of relevant experience], I was hoping we could look at a salary of £[Counter Offer Amount].
I appreciate there may be internal salary bands to consider, but I wanted to ask whether there is any flexibility before I make a final decision.
Thanks again, and I look forward to hearing your thoughts.
Kind regards,
[Your Name]
This is the kind of email recruiters can actually forward internally without needing to tidy it up.
That matters more than candidates realise.
A recruiter may need to send your request to a hiring manager and say, “The candidate is really interested, but they are looking for £X. Is there any room in the budget?”
If your email is clear, respectful, and reasonable, you make that internal conversation easier. If your email is messy, defensive, or overly long, the recruiter has to translate it. And when recruiters have to translate your message, you lose control of how your request is presented.
If you have another offer, you can mention it, but carefully. This is where candidates often become clumsy.
Another offer can strengthen your position, but it can also make you look transactional if handled badly. The goal is not to threaten the employer. The goal is to explain your decision context.
Weak Example
I have another offer for more money, so can you match it?
This sounds blunt and gives the employer no sense that you prefer them.
Good Example
Hi [Name],
Thank you again for the offer. I’m really pleased to have received it, and [Company Name] remains a role I’m very interested in.
I wanted to be transparent that I’m also considering another offer with a higher overall package. My preference is still to continue the conversation with [Company Name], as I feel the role is a strong fit for my experience and career direction.
Would there be any flexibility to review the salary and move closer to £[Counter Offer Amount]? If that were possible, it would make the decision much easier for me.
Thanks again, and I appreciate you taking the time to consider this.
Kind regards,
[Your Name]
This works because it does not use the other offer as a weapon. It uses it as context.
There is a big difference between:
“Pay me more or I’m leaving.”
And:
“I’m interested, but I need the package to be competitive enough for me to accept.”
This situation needs a slightly firmer tone. If the employer gave a range earlier and the offer comes in below it, you are allowed to question that.
Be careful, though. You still want to sound professional, not accusatory.
Example
Subject: Re: Offer for [Job Title]
Hi [Name],
Thank you for sending over the offer. I’m excited about the opportunity and appreciate the time the team has taken throughout the process.
I wanted to clarify the salary point before making a decision. Earlier in the process, we discussed a range of £[Range] for the role, so I was slightly surprised to see the offer come through at £[Offer Amount].
Based on the range discussed and the responsibilities of the position, would there be flexibility to revise the offer to £[Counter Offer Amount]?
I remain very interested in the role and would be happy to discuss this further.
Kind regards,
[Your Name]
This is direct without being aggressive.
The phrase “I wanted to clarify” is useful because it gives the employer a chance to explain. Sometimes there is a genuine reason. Sometimes there has been a misunderstanding. Sometimes, frankly, someone is trying their luck.
Candidates often worry about sounding difficult here. I would worry more about accepting an offer that already feels misaligned before you have even started.
Not every counter offer is about salary. In the UK, candidates increasingly look at the full package: pension contributions, bonus, private medical cover, hybrid working, annual leave, working hours, flexibility, travel expectations, and professional development.
Sometimes an employer cannot move much on salary but can improve the overall value.
Example
Subject: Re: [Job Title] Offer
Hi [Name],
Thank you for the offer. I’m really pleased to have received it and I’m very interested in joining [Company Name].
I’ve reviewed the details and wanted to ask whether there is any flexibility around [specific benefit, such as hybrid working, annual leave, bonus, or professional development support].
The salary is close to what I had in mind, but the overall package would be easier for me to accept if we could explore [specific request].
I’d be grateful to understand what flexibility may be possible.
Kind regards,
[Your Name]
This is particularly useful when the employer has a strict salary band.
A lot of candidates only negotiate base salary and forget the rest of the package. That can be a mistake. A slightly lower salary with better flexibility, stronger pension, less commuting, more annual leave, or meaningful bonus potential may be more valuable than a higher salary that quietly drains your life.
Very glamorous, I know. But so is not spending half your week on delayed trains.
Your counter offer should usually be ambitious enough to matter, but reasonable enough to justify.
As a rough guide, many candidates ask for something in the range of 5% to 10% above the initial offer, depending on the role, market, seniority, and whether the employer has already met the discussed salary range.
For senior, specialist, or hard to fill roles, there may be more room. For structured graduate schemes, public sector roles, unionised environments, or companies with rigid salary bands, there may be less.
The real question is not “How much can I get away with asking for?”
The better question is:
“What figure would make this offer a confident yes, and can I justify that figure using the role scope, market, and my value?”
That is a much stronger way to think.
Do not choose a counter offer number randomly. Choose it based on:
The salary range advertised
The salary discussed with the recruiter
Your current compensation
The market rate for similar UK roles
Some counter offer emails fail because the candidate asks for too much. More often, they fail because the tone is wrong.
Avoid saying:
“This offer is disappointing”
“I know my worth”
“Can you do better?”
“I need more because of my personal expenses”
“The salary is too low for someone like me”
“Other companies would pay more”
“I expected a stronger offer”
“Let me know your best and final”
This is the part most candidates never see.
When you send a counter offer email, the recruiter is not always the final decision maker. They may need to go back to the hiring manager, HR, finance, or compensation team. Their willingness to push for you depends on several things.
They are likely to advocate for you if:
You are the preferred candidate
Your request is within or close to the approved salary band
You performed strongly throughout the interview process
The hiring manager is worried about losing you
The role has been difficult to fill
Your skills are scarce in the UK market
In many cases, the best approach is both.
A phone conversation is useful because tone is easier. You can sound enthusiastic, ask questions, and understand whether there is flexibility. But email is useful because it creates a clear written record of your request.
My usual advice is this:
Use the phone if you have a good relationship with the recruiter or hiring manager, especially if the offer is complex. Then follow up by email with the agreed details or your formal request.
Use email if you need to be precise, if you feel nervous, or if you want to avoid being pressured into answering too quickly.
There is no prize for negotiating live if you are going to panic and accept something you do not want.
A simple phone opener could be:
“Thank you again for the offer. I’m really interested in the role. I wanted to talk through the salary before I formally respond, as I was hoping there may be some flexibility.”
Then follow with an email:
“Following our conversation, I wanted to confirm that I would be comfortable accepting at £X, subject to the final written offer.”
That combination is often very effective because it keeps the relationship human while making the details clear.
If the employer says no, your response matters.
A no does not always mean they do not value you. It may mean the role has a fixed band, internal equity issues, budget restrictions, or approval limits. Sometimes companies genuinely cannot move. Sometimes they can move, but not enough. Sometimes the recruiter already fought the battle before the offer reached you.
You have three choices:
Accept the offer as it stands
Ask whether there is flexibility elsewhere in the package
Decline professionally
If you still want the role, respond positively.
Example
Hi [Name],
Thank you for checking and coming back to me. I appreciate you looking into it.
I understand there may be limits around the salary. Before I make a final decision, would there be any flexibility around [annual leave, hybrid working, bonus, review timeline, or professional development support]?
I remain very interested in the role and would like to see whether we can find a package that works for both sides.
Kind regards,
[Your Name]
If you decide to decline, do it cleanly.
The most common mistakes are not complicated. They are usually avoidable.
The first mistake is being too vague. “Is there room to improve the offer?” is not terrible, but it is weaker than giving a specific number. Employers are not mind readers. A clear figure helps them assess feasibility.
The second mistake is writing too much. Long counter offer emails often sound defensive. You do not need six paragraphs explaining why you deserve more. If the employer has offered you the job, they already see value. Your email should sharpen the commercial point, not re interview for the role.
The third mistake is making it personal. Your bills are not the employer’s pricing model. I say that with sympathy, not coldness. Personal circumstances may explain why you need more, but they rarely persuade a company to increase an offer.
The fourth mistake is sounding like you are not interested. Some candidates negotiate so coolly that the employer starts wondering whether they even want the job. Always confirm interest before making the request.
The fifth mistake is bluffing. Do not invent another offer. Recruiters can often sense when something does not add up. Even if they cannot prove it, your credibility takes a hit.
The sixth mistake is negotiating after accepting. Once you have accepted an offer, trying to reopen salary can damage trust quickly. If you need to negotiate, do it before you accept.
The seventh mistake is ignoring the full package. Salary matters, of course. But so do pension, bonus, annual leave, working hours, hybrid policy, location, travel, private healthcare, training budget, and review timelines.
The eighth mistake is treating the recruiter like an obstacle. A good recruiter can be your advocate internally. Give them a clear, reasonable case they can take forward.
A strong counter offer email follows this simple structure:
Thank them for the offer
Confirm genuine interest
Identify the specific issue
Give your preferred figure or request
Justify it briefly
Ask whether there is flexibility
Close positively
Here is the formula in plain language:
“Thank you for the offer. I’m interested in the role. I’d like to discuss the salary. Based on the role scope and my experience, I was hoping for £X. Is there flexibility to move closer to this? If so, I would be comfortable moving forward.”
Use this version if you want one polished, flexible email that works for most UK job offer situations.
Example
Subject: Re: Offer for [Job Title]
Hi [Name],
Thank you again for the offer for the [Job Title] role. I really appreciate the time you and the team have taken throughout the process, and I’m genuinely excited about the opportunity to join [Company Name].
I’ve reviewed the offer carefully and wanted to ask whether there is any flexibility on the salary. Based on the responsibilities we discussed, the level of experience I would bring, and the market rate for similar roles, I was hoping we could explore a salary of £[Counter Offer Amount].
I remain very interested in the position, and if there is flexibility to move closer to that figure, I would feel comfortable moving forward.
Thanks again for considering this, and I’d be happy to discuss if helpful.
Kind regards,
[Your Name]
This email works because it does not apologise for negotiating, but it also does not turn the conversation into a power struggle.
That is the balance candidates need.
The best negotiation emails make the employer feel that improving the offer will secure a motivated, professional candidate. They do not make the employer feel cornered.
Written by Simar Malhi, a recruiter and headhunter with international recruitment experience. I write about CVs, job applications, hiring decisions, and the reality behind recruitment processes. My goal is to help candidates understand more honestly how employers, recruiters, and hiring managers actually select candidates.
Use ATS-optimised Resume and resume templates that pass applicant tracking systems. Our Resume builder helps recruiters read, scan, and shortlist your Resume faster.
Use professional field-tested resume templates that follow the exact Resume rules employers look for.
Create Resume
Use professional field-tested resume templates that follow the exact Resume rules employers look for.
Create ResumeIs this about salary only, or are there wider concerns?
A strong counter offer email answers those questions before the employer has to ask them.
The mistake I see candidates make is assuming the email should be persuasive in a dramatic way. It does not need to be dramatic. It needs to be usable. A recruiter often has to take your request to a hiring manager, HR, finance, or compensation team. If your email is clear and sensible, you make it easier for them to advocate for you.
If your email sounds emotional, vague, or inflated, you make their job harder. And when you make the internal process harder, you reduce your chances of getting a better offer.
You are excited about the role but need the package to make commercial sense
You should be more careful if:
The employer has already stretched to meet your stated expectations
You gave a clear salary expectation and the offer matches it
You are negotiating over a very small difference that will not change your decision
The role is already at the top of its salary band
You are using negotiation as a way to hide uncertainty about the role
That last one is common. Sometimes candidates think they are negotiating salary, but what they are really feeling is doubt. Doubt about the manager. Doubt about the company. Doubt about the role scope. Doubt about leaving their current job.
A higher salary can make a good opportunity better. It rarely fixes a bad opportunity.
The number is not ridiculous
I can take this to the hiring manager
They have given us a chance to respond before walking away
That is the sweet spot.
That may sound blunt, but it is useful. Your counter offer email should focus on the employer’s decision logic, not your personal stress.
Better reasons include:
The responsibilities are wider than expected
The market rate for similar UK roles is higher
Your experience matches a more senior level within the band
Another offer is stronger
The total package is lower because of pension, bonus, flexibility, or benefits
The salary is below the range discussed earlier
The strongest counter offers are not emotional. They are commercially reasonable.
It gives the employer room to respond
It avoids sounding like an ultimatum
The phrase “is there any flexibility” is useful because it sounds collaborative rather than confrontational. You are not demanding. You are opening a negotiation.
The second one is much easier for an employer to respond to positively.
The level of responsibility
The urgency of the hire
Your fit compared with the likely candidate pool
The strength of your interview feedback
The value of the wider package
Whether you are prepared to walk away
That final point matters. Never negotiate as if you are willing to walk away if you are absolutely not willing to walk away. You do not need to be reckless, but you do need to know your own line.
“I cannot accept unless you increase it”
Now, some of these thoughts may be understandable. But understandable does not mean useful.
“I know my worth” is one of those phrases that sounds empowering online and slightly exhausting in an actual hiring process. Employers do not respond to slogans. They respond to evidence, fit, market logic, and whether they can get approval.
Use calm, specific language instead.
Weak Example
I know my worth and expected a much better offer.
Good Example
Based on the responsibilities discussed and the market level for similar roles, I was hoping we could explore a salary closer to £[Amount].
The good version is more likely to get you what you want because it gives the employer something practical to work with.
Your communication has been professional
You have given a clear acceptance path
That last point is important.
If you say, “If you can offer £X, I would be happy to accept,” that gives the employer confidence. It tells them there is a real outcome if they move.
If you say, “Can you increase the offer?” without explaining what would make the offer acceptable, the employer may wonder whether you will keep negotiating again after they improve it.
Hiring teams do not like open ended negotiation. They prefer clarity.
A good counter offer email should make the employer think:
“If we can get this approved, we probably secure the candidate.”
That is exactly the position you want to create.
Example
Hi [Name],
Thank you again for the offer and for taking the time to review my request.
After careful consideration, I’ve decided not to move forward on this occasion, as the overall package is not quite aligned with what I’m looking for at this stage.
I really appreciate the opportunity and enjoyed speaking with the team. I wish you all the best with the hire.
Kind regards,
[Your Name]
Do not burn the relationship. The UK job market is smaller than people think, especially within specialist sectors. People move companies, recruiters remember professional candidates, and hiring managers sometimes come back later with a better role.
Leave the door open unless there is a very good reason not to.
That is the whole logic.
Candidates often overcomplicate this because salary negotiation feels uncomfortable. But discomfort is not a reason to write a strange email.
Keep it clear. Keep it respectful. Keep it specific.
A good counter offer email does not need to sound powerful. It needs to sound credible.
Upload Resume
Import from Linkedin